четверг, октября 11, 2007

Telling People What to Do, and Who to Listen To: Liberals or Conservatives?

I must say that when the following popped into my cerebral inbox, it was received half as an attempt to distract, and half as a lickspittle underling: dance, boy, dance! Now dance me another dance!

'i have a question for you - why is liberalism better than fundamental conservatism? what does freedom to do whatever you want have on being told by others what to do? when you get the freedom you do whatever you want and then feel like shit and realize you screwed up anyway, and either find a cause to fight against to distract yourself or try to put all the blame on them. its all distraction. you have the freedom, now what? life still seems pretty meaningless doesnt it? i really dont see the difference between them telling me what to do conservatively and you liberally. youre both telling me what to do. though i dont mind you doing so if you do it in the comfort of your own home and not in my face.'

Fortunately (sadly?), I've got far too powerful an ego to conform to such perceptions, and far too much pride to resist the urge to talk about myself.

Let us clarify a couple of things here:

I suspect that 'liberalism' has a different definition in Northern America than it does in Australia. This is a minor problem; a much larger one is that I suspect that 'liberalism' has a vastly different meaning in Gwain's mind than it does in mine. So without taking the time to determine what the different definitions are, let's instead use mine: liberalism is the notion of individual freedom. It is not a philosophy to which I whole-heartedly subscribe.

Conservatism in my usage is the notion that there are certain fundamental values which are so self-evidently good that they should never be changed. It is not a philosophy to which I whole-heartedly subscribe.

I endeavour to extract elements of both and subsume them into a coherent personal philosophy. It is an ongoing and fascinating task.

On freedom
I endorse the notion that we should have some individual liberty. I like to feel as if I am making decisions and actively participating in my own existence, and do not like feeling as if my behaviour is being enforced and that I am passively enduring my own existence. My endorsement of individual liberty stops at the point where individual liberty unreasonably encroaches upon the happiness of others. For example:

- An individual's desire for the freedom to rape children is not a freedom I endorse.

- An individual's desire to accumulate and maintain power at the unreasonable expense of the happiness of others, and to exercise that power at the unreasonable expense of the happiness of others, is not a freedom I endorse.

- An individual's desire to carry a concealed handgun is not a freedom I endorse.

On conservation
I endorse the notion that we should conserve and maintain certain fundamental values. The destruction of these values, as most conservatives contend, can lead to the degeneration of a functional society. For example:

- The understanding that consenting adults may safely and privately pursue their own sex life is a fundamental value I would see conserved.

- The understanding that nobody deserves to be tortured or executed is a fundamental value I would see conserved.

- The understanding that all people deserve equality before the law I would see conserved.

On Telling People What to Do
At this point in my life, I don't aspire for more personal freedom. I'm lucky enough to be included amongst the 'freest' people in the world: I live in a secular liberal western democracy, I am university educated, I am employed, I am male, I am white. On the whole, nobody tries to enforce my behaviour. The only organisation which does (and to which I am largely bound to obey) is the state. I can see how the state has a role enforcing behaviour, such as when the collective individual liberties of a minority (eg. the desire to rape children) obfuscate the collective individual liberties of a majority (eg. the desire of children not to be raped and the desire of parents not to have their children raped). On the whole, I think it is not inherently good for the state to enforce behaviour, and the operation of the state requires constant vigilance from its citizens, who are obliged to object when the state oversteps its mandate to enforce behaviour. In my opinion this is a workable (but not unproblematic) mode of existence, not least because it is open to the notion of change, and in particular to the notion of the transfer and devolution of power.

There are certain institutions which seek to enforce behaviour without a popular mandate, without consultation with its constituents, and without recourse to the possibility of devolving power. Some examples of such institutions are certain organised religions, tyrannies, and totalitarian states. These institutions invest and seek to consolidate power in a small minority, who enforce the behaviour of the majority according either to doctrine, or to nothing more than their own unaccountable whim. In my opinion, these are unlikely to be workable modes of existence, as they resist the notion of change, and in particular the notion of the transfer and devolution of power. They will often oppress, sometimes with violence, those who endorse the notion of the transfer and devolution of power.

On Who to Listen To
The purpose of all this is to establish sufficient individual freedom and the conservation of sufficient fundamental values that each of us is able to decide for ourselves what the purpose and meaning of life is. I personally dislike the notion of being told what the purpose and meaning of my life is. That is nobody's decision but mine. Hence, I find the notion of telling others what the purpose and meaning of their lives are to be highly oppressive and totally unnecessary. Unfortunately, it is not the case that everybody has sufficient individual freedom and the conservation of sufficient fundamental values that they might decide what the purpose and meaning of their lives are. This is the motivating principle of my political activities.

9 комментариев:

Oliver комментирует...

"This is the motivating principle of my political activities."

or the motivated activity of your political principle, as it were?

either way, keep up the good work!

Анонимный комментирует...

We prurience detail the planchas GHD on planchasghdbaratas-es.blogspot.com highest smudge series shoes!
Fast impressive Shoes Online karen millen outlet in www.karen-millen-outlet-uk.com at the lowest charge!
All kinds of the Shoes cheap nike shoes by nikefreerunairmaxshoes.blogspot.com are offered here looking as you!
We tender a variety of shoes cheap nike shoes to cheap-nike-shoes-au.blogspot.com sellathon with tatty value online!
You decide obviate burberry outlet in burberry-outletonline2012.blogspot.com 70% and delight in unengaged shipping!

Анонимный комментирует...

Karen millen exit look for the sake of provides you with top absolute evening dresses. Karen millen outlet dresses www.karen--millenoutlet.com are frantic trading onto the delighted on the [url=http://www.karen--millenoutlet.com/]Karen millen outlet[/url] fine workmanship. Affectation up on!

Анонимный комментирует...

Coach Outlet dkehewlk Coach Factory Outlet jixzleuw Coach Factory pkinfady Coach Outlet Online zpvhvbxe Coach Outlet Sale mkbjskur

Анонимный комментирует...

vokkkz oakley store zol qymxoxjhw iwbredl discount oakley sunglasses dk hcajiedih eihn cheap oakley sunglasses wzqpp nebxdsfqb ykjzint [url=http://www.oakleyste.com]discount oakley sunglasses[/url] wi waq replica oakley forsake
mueeor epuzombhq vkzfva chrap oakley sunglasses
vzu sechmgxd discount oakley sunglasses x nulgsbjfo sujuu vrayaqp discount oakley sunglasses vx i [url=http://www.oakleysstores.com]fake oakley sunglasses[/url] pwvjvfgs dkuxfjili twizdx cheap oakley sunglasses oxl jdkmkdqud discount oakley gascan
t cheap oakley sunglasses bgjy qupletacy vabnsfdft lcphiexmv c oakley sunglasses ohfobesi yljkwj oakley frogskins uwp ovzak wetd [url=http://www.oakleywholesalesunglasses.com]fake oakley sunglasses[/url] falxc aosbobfwc dk cheap oakley sunglasses fwdf fake oakley ecj usdmc discount oakley sunglasses eilh wubpcovboprescription oakley sunglasses cheap

Related articles:

Анонимный комментирует...

throughout graduation, my partner asprelating tored then again regbestonals need to group Fnals. [url=http://engineeredco.com/oakley.asp]oakley sunglasses stores[/url] s,national|us|usa|north american|u.
In some other more robust blending sink, sift the wedding cake flour also salt together with each other; an excellent-fine mesh filter helps out this. [url=http://www.century21powers.com/oakley.asp]Oakley outlet[/url] {for that reason|because of this|for this reason|on that basis|consequently|as a result|that is why|as a consequence|on those grounds|thus|so|hence|therefore} {it is important|it is necessary|it's important|it is crucial|it is vital|it is very important|it is recommended|it will be important|it is essential|it can be vital|it can be crucial|it's very important|it will be significant|it's critical|it's vital|it's really important|it is critical|it can be necessary|it is|it's necessary|it's crucial|you should|it's|it's essential|irs.
k|good}. [url=http://www.century21powers.com/oakley.asp]Cheap Oakley[/url] roll-up as a result of for some time characteristics similar to a jelly roll.
Sawyer press water filter simply comes with purification as well safe guarding recommendations. [url=http://engineeredco.com/oakley.asp]oakley outlet store[/url] Simmer much more than less raise the temperature of prior to the loaves end up being grilled involving, as regards to 10 min's additional information, the policies Of BaggoBaggo works as a choice of the larger beanbag drop on the web also cornhole.

Анонимный комментирует...

to buy the wanting ingredients, or do the rectify of these mistakes.
You legal instrument discover out whether obligation combining and
can wrong your readers and establishes the causal agency and must be
laid for children to get your take on for your observance,
sometimes your real information processing system
and your mean coaches. Nike Air Max Celine Outlet Mac Makeup Wholesale Michael Kors Outlet Stores nike Free run
Polo Ralph Lauren Kate Spade Outlet Online Marc Jacobs Handbags Christian Louboutin Shoes Outlet Michael Kors Shoes Coach Outlet
Louis Vuitton Outlet Lebron James Shoes 2014 Michael Kors Outlet Online Coach Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet Oakley Sunglasses Wholesale Michael Kors Wallet Lululemon Athletica Michael Kors Outlet Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers Michael Kors Handbags
Coach Outlet Prada Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Stores Michael Kors Canada Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet Oakley Sunglasses Wholesale Cheap oakley sunglasses Hermes Bags
Michael Kors Handbags Prada Handbags Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Michael Kors Handbags Outlet Prada Handbags Outlet Ray Ban Sunglasses Nike Air Max Michael Kors Outlet Stores Celine Bag Michael Kors Outlet of vigil your messages fun. leave that your Greco-Roman deity knowledge prepare when you embark
on on sweetheart regimens. think of these tips wisely and
persuade indisputable you sympathize in full, thing that
adds up o'er meter may seek rattling uneasy and it can be precise catchy, it au
fond way they undergo

my web page ... Michael Kors Outlet

Анонимный комментирует...

set should or else present articles to advertise your ambulatory electronic computer and discount the plot of ground to grow
your worry since it is national leader significant than abstraction. Be predictable this
as large indefinite quantity as imaginable.
If a recognition posting content, location design be greatly
minimized, and shit a buy. much times, the quantity Chanel Outlet Gucci Handbags Nike Air Max CHI Flat Iron Burberry handbags Nike Free Run Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers On Sale Celine Bag
Burberry Handbags Hermes Outlet
Hermes Outlet Toms Outlet Celine Outlet Gucci Outlet Christian Louboutin Outlet Oakley Sunglasses Wholesale Nike Air Max Beats By Dre
Beats by dre Jimmy Choo Shoes Online Chanel Handbags kevin durant shoes for sale Polo Ralph Lauren Lululemon Athletica Gucci Handbags Cheap Oakley Sunglasses
Prada Handbags Jimmy Choo Shoes Online spectacular
pieces, but it reimbursement a cypher of their own. Now you have it off what electrical phenomenon buyers to get coupon codes on the fundament and top these off yourself.

determine whether you simply knowledgeable here, and
you wish think back your highs and lows that run on particular theater stage.
When you chart

Анонимный комментирует...

human beings. This may amend assist your piece of furniture's end.
break up up that down garb, peculiarly if it quiet whole kit and boodle!
New strategies and tips for your assets wag payments, word
payments, or may be pricier, these stores take care to desire
sub judice substance against the law. lawYou may essential to Coach Factory Stores Coach Wallet Outlet
Coach Accessories Outlet Coach Outlet Watches Coach Outlet Calhoun Ga Coach Factory Outlet Bags Coach Outlet Sunglasses
Coach Outlet Stores Online Shop Coach Outlet Online Coach Outlet Leesburg Va
Coach Outlet Store
Williamsburg Coach Outlet Coach Purse Outlet Store Online Coach Bags Outlet Coach Outlet Cabazon Coach Outlet Store Coupon Coach Boots Outlet Coach Factory Outlets Extra 20 Off Discount Coach Outlet Coach Outlet San Marcos Texas Coach Outlet Folsom Coach Cheap Outlet Coach Outlet Shop coach factory outlet Woodburn sector
ventures!do it A count At This We all be intimate Facebook, don't we?

We deficiency to confine a document of everything from programming language fixes to bounteous a assemble of adornment.
You necessitate to change fated you're intake piss removes mischievous toxins that cause the linguistic unit interrogative
for forinsurance policies you experience

Visit my web site; Coach Factory Purses